Home Up Cattle Camels Horses Home Use Mosquitoes Bibliography

Mosquitoes, Black Flies & No-seeums

"Backyard" propane-powered traps that dispense carbon dioxide as an attractant have now been available to consumers for several years for mosquito control, e.g. the Dragonfly® Trap of Biosensory Inc., the Mosquito Magnet of American Biophysics Corp., the Mosquito Deleto™ of Coleman, the MegaCatch of Envirosafe Technologies, and others. The efficacy of consumer-oriented trapping is gradually being documented in the scientific literature (downloadable articles on mosquitoes by Daniel Kline, June, 2002 and on biting midges by Cilek et al., Jun, 2003). The Journal of the American Mosquito Control Association, Volume 22, Number 3, September 2006 contains several relevant papers (abstracts only) and should be consulted by any consumer who is  contemplating the use of traps. In this recent issue, there is an eminently practical test of the Mosquito Magnetin Manitoba (Henderson et al., pp. 401-407) that is particularly interesting for those of us who live in Canada and are "eaten alive" by Aedes vexans in the summer (they found that traps failed to "significantly reduce mosquito activity"). The issue also contains the following review paper:

bullet

Kline, D.L. (2006) Traps and trapping techniques for adult mosquito control. Journal of the American Mosquito Control Association, 22, 490-496.

Traps area discussed in a position paper provided by the American Mosquito Control Association in their information section on mosquitoes. This organization, and others, provide useful information on mosquito biology, sampling and control. I have found a document produced by Health Canada particularly useful as an introduction to this field (Municipal Mosquito Control Guidelines). The Canada Communicable Disease Report (Vol. 31, 2005) also contains a free PDF guide to Personal Protective Measures to Prevent Arthropod Bites.

The Nzi trap was not developed to control mosquitoes, black flies, midges, etc. Nevertheless, it is capable of catching these smaller biting flies when baited with appropriate attractants and when equipped with netting of an appropriate mesh size. Below, I provide the few insights I have acquired in limited efforts to target these insects.

Mosquitoes

On the whole, mosquito catches are unpredictable relative to biting rates as species differences in behaviour towards traps are huge. The best example I have is from late June, 2005 near Great Slave Lake in the Northwest Territories. At extremely high densities of mosquitoes, I found considerable mosquito activity on and around traps, and yet surprisingly few mosquitoes entered traps. Below are some of my experiences at different locations where I have trapped on a more regular basis.

Since I started routine trapping at my home in Russell, Ontario, the highest catch I have obtained in an unbaited Nzi trap is 121 Aedes per day (mostly female A. vexans). Daily catches of a few to tens of mosquitoes are typical. By baiting a trap with carbon dioxide (dry ice) and octenol (Biosensory octenol lure), I have been able to catch 712 mosquitoes per day (I tried this bait on two nights only). Only some species of Aedes appear to be susceptible to trapping, with low catches of other taxa. Catches are particularly good for spring Aedes (e.g. A. punctor), which are active during the day.

The overnight catch on 18, July 2002

Moquito Catch 79kThe mosquitoes were caught between 8 pm and 8 am in a Nzi trap baited with 5 kg dry ice and a Biosensory octenol lure at 23 °C, 80% Relative Humidity, and 14 km/h wind speed (means for the night). Most were the annoying man-biting species Aedes vexans. Codes for other components of the catch are: An - Anopheles punctipennis, BF - Simulium Black flies, Tabanus - Tabanus quinquevittatus.

Anopheles punctipennis (Intel® PlayTM QX3TM Computer Microscope)

Anopheles punctipennis Head 22kAnopheles punctipennis Wing 29kThis is an interesting mosquito present in small numbers later in the summer. Historically, malaria was found in this area; transmission is obviously still theoretically possible.

During trap development work in Africa, unbaited traps also caught few mosquitoes, but I mostly worked in areas with low populations. However, in Kenya, I occasionally baited traps with carbon dioxide when mosquitoes were present. This resulted in the capture of 50 -100 mosquitoes in a residential area of Nairobi, and many thousands of mosquitoes in a more natural area at Shompole (a swamp near Lake Natron). The Nairobi catch was mainly Culex quinquefasciatus, plus a few Anopheles funestus and Anopheles gambiae. The catch at Shompole was never identified.

I also tested carbon dioxide as an attractant at the AAFC dairy in 1999.

Aedes dorsalis 17k

Aedes dorsalis

In August at Lethbridge, Alberta, I baited a Nzi trap with enough dry ice to last about 12 hours on separate days. The trap caught 61 mosquitoes during the day, and 127 at night. Unbaited traps caught only a few individuals per day through the summer. Aedes dorsalis accounted for most of the catch. Culiseta inornata was also captured.

Black Flies

Simulium 14kI have rarely set Nzi traps in areas with many black flies (Simuliidae). However, in August 1995, by a small stream in Nairobi (my former home), I captured 200+ black flies when a trap was baited with dry ice. This was a surprise, as I had been trapping on a regular basis with octenol, and had never noticed their presence. Unfortunately, most of my early work with Nzi traps was with very wide mesh netting. Hence, I probably missed the presence of low numbers of black flies (mesh sizes). I have obtained similar results at my current home in Russell, Ontario. When a trap is baited with carbon dioxide, it will catch black flies, even if they are not readily-apparent in the environment.

For a proper test at the right time of the year in an area with many black flies, I set a few octenol-baited Nzi traps at two locations near Great Slave Lake, Northwest Territories in late June, 2005. By using fine netting to retain all small flies, I obtained catches of up to 5,000 black flies per day. Obviously, one could get truly amazing catches of black flies with the use of carbon dioxide-baited traps.

No-Seeums

Atrichopogon Midge 11kAs with black flies, I have never paid much attention to the presence of Ceratopogonidae in Nzi traps, but this is simply because I have always used wide mesh netting that allows these tiny flies to escape. In 2003, I monitored the catch of small flies in an octenol-baited Nzi trap made with very fine "no-seeum" netting at my home in Russell, Ontario. I monitored the catch early and late in the season. At these times, the trap caught only a few biting midges per day. The catch of other tiny non-biting insects was sometimes quite high.

Ceratopogonidae may simply not be abundant in Russell; I hardly ever notice bites from no-seeums. It is therefore hard to know if this was a useful test of trap performance or not. About the only interesting finding was the unexpected capture of >100 no-seeums (mostly females) on a single, unusually warm day in early September. These midges were likely Atrichopogon (Richard Lancaster, Lethbridge Research Centre).

 

Updated
01-Mar-2007